Blog Layout

Read My Opinion Piece on Türkiye and Nato

The bottom line: Türkiye should approve Sweden’s admission to NATO immediately after its presidential elections on May 14. This is long overdue, serving only to hurt NATO unity and readiness, and sending a wrong message to Putin that could embolden him.


Read the Fox News Article Below,


Turkey's Erdogan Stockholm syndrome pleases Putin, threatens NATO

I sometimes felt Turkey's Erdogan was a bigger challenge to NATO than Putin


 By Dr. Mark T. Esper | Fox News


The Republic of Turkey will hold a presidential election on May 14. Its significance to the people of that ancient land and extraordinary country cannot be overstated. Nor can its importance to the future of NATO and security in Europe.


The incumbent, President Tayyip Erdogan, has ruled for two decades with an increasingly authoritarian bent. He now faces a unified opposition that probably presents his greatest electoral challenge ever. Many critics note that Erdogan has overseen an economy wracked by high inflation and turmoil, undermined democratic principles, pulled the country to the hard right, and responded slowly to the devastating earthquake that killed tens of thousands a few months ago. His response is to score points beyond Turkey's borders


On the international stage, Erdogan has played various roles, usually taking on issues and pursuing strategies that promote his profile abroad and his political support back home. During my time at the Pentagon, I sometimes felt he was a bigger challenge to NATO than Vladimir Putin. This is not easy to say. After all, Turkey is one of the oldest, more capable, and strategic members of the alliance since joining in 1952. Yet just a few years ago, Erdogan kept Washington busy with one issue after another: from threatening our fellow ally Greece and aggressively challenging French warships in the Mediterranean, to blocking the approval of NATO war plans in Brussels and buying advanced air defense systems – designed to defeat U.S. aircraft -- from Moscow, just to name a few.


Fast forward a few years, and the friction has only grown as the stakes have increased. Ankara is now the primary obstacle to Sweden joining NATO, and is doing so amid the most destructive conflict in Europe since WWII. It’s a patently political move that surely pleases Moscow.


Many believe that by taking such a tough stance against Sweden (and Finland until recently), Erdogan is aiming to consolidate his support in nationalist circles prior to the upcoming election. His argument – Stockholm has not done enough to support Turkey decades-long fight against the PKK.


Ankara has legitimate concerns about the outlawed Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK), which the U.S., EU, and Sweden have rightly identified as a foreign terrorist organization. Since the 1980s, the PKK has been waging an insurgency against Turkey in which more than 40,000 people have been killed. This is often the lens through which Erdogan sees (or interprets) many things. 


As such, Sweden has taken several steps over the past year to address his concerns, from amending its constitution and passing legislation that tightens the country’s anti-terrorism laws, to taking a harder line toward the PKK (and their affiliates) and ending its arms embargo against Ankara. These steps and others were included in a trilateral memorandum agreed to last year by Finland, Sweden, and Turkey. Yet as time passed and the election neared, Erdogan continued to up the ante for Stockholm by adding new demands.


There is no doubt that Sweden’s membership in NATO would improve this historic alliance. Over the years, this proud Scandinavian country has conducted military exercises with NATO, shared intelligence, developed effective weapons and equipment, and ensured its armed forces (especially its maritime capabilities) are modern and compatible with its future allies. It needs to spend much more on defense as a share of GDP, but it has contributed generously to Ukraine and its geography enhances the security of both the Baltic Sea and the Arctic.


Turkey's election is just days away. Meanwhile, war rages in Ukraine as frontline allies and non-NATO European states like Sweden worry if they are next on Putin’s menu. At this point, there is not much else to be done until the polls close on May 14. But after that, the U.S. and its allies should demand Ankara immediately approve Sweden’s admission to the alliance.


President Erdogan has been given more than enough time to do the right thing. If he doesn’t budge, then it’s time to dramatically increase the pressure and take the actions necessary that would result in a greenlight for Stockholm. Otherwise, we risk sending a message of disunity to Moscow that could embolden their operations in Ukraine, and Putin’s broader aspirations in the region. Admitting Sweden to NATO, on the other hand, would not just improve that country’s security, but would enhance the security of all other NATO allies as well, including (ironically) Turkey.


Dr. Mark T. Esper was the 27th secretary of Defense and 23rd secretary of the Army, and author of the NYT bestselling memoir "A Sacred Oath: Memoirs Of A Secretary Of Defense During Extraordinary Times."

19 Apr, 2024
As I told Wolf Blitzer - Israel sent a clear message today: we can strike the interior of Iran if we want and have the will to do so. Last week’s defeat of Iran’s missile strikes was defense; today was deterrence. It’s overdue for the West to unite and compel better behavior from Iran or the cycle continues. Watch the Interview Here.
17 Apr, 2024
Bill Kristol and I discuss the state of the world. Watch the Interview Here.
16 Apr, 2024
“Nobody wants a wider regional war. But we arguably are on the precipice of that right now. This could get very big, very quickly,” I said to Christiane Amanpour while I criticized the Biden administration's response, arguing that Israel has to respond. Watch the Interview Here .
15 Apr, 2024
Wolf Blitzer and I discuss the ongoing Israel and Iran situation. Watch the Interview Here .
15 Apr, 2024
"My view is Israel probably has to strike back hard and try to reestablish deterrence and make sure the Iranians know that they can’t strike Israel with 300-plus missiles and drones with impunity," I said to the DC Examiner. Read the Article Here .
15 Apr, 2024
Solid piece but for one error: we moved Israel into CENTCOM at end of Trump term for the reasons this conflict is exposing. I had great support from Mike Pompeo to push this. See page 185 of "A Sacred Oath" for the how and why we did this. Read the Article Here .
More Posts →
Share by: